When I rode the LandRider which shifted 7 engine/human driven gears automatically, I used rim brakes. Bike/rider weight was 350 lbs. I also live in the mountains. Down hill speeds can reach 50 mph. With rim brakes pads aren't created equally; a good quality compound pad is a must. Things like bump braking and longer stopping distance is required.Wow... 35Mph on a Bicycle... I have an Ebike and it pretty much tops out at 25, which just feels wrong for a bicycle. And, to be fair, I upgraded the hell out of the bike! It's got:
Thornproof tubes (26x1.75)
tight pattern knobby tires (Good for the street, not so for off road)
Stem riser, wider bars, and a nice fat ass gel seat
It came with disc brakes front and rear (180F/160R) but I upgraded both to 203mm discs and ceramic pads front and rear
Tail light with turn signals (headlight came with the eBike motor kit)
It's a suspension fork/hardtail, 7 speed freewheel, running 46t to 12t in 7th. I was going to upgrade the back wheell to a 8 speed internal drive to eliminate the derailluer, but my last surgery destroyed my left knee, so now I don't even ride it anymore. It's sitting in my living room collecting dust.
I feel for you, man, but I've been riding motorcycles for 20+ years, and while 35 is slow on them, 35 on a bicycle is downright insane, especially with lackluster brakes and stock rubber. As soon as you pass 15mph, you really need Discs and calipers. Rim-rider brakes are a recipe for disaster.
With either type, heat is your enemy. At least with an open to the air rotor, heat is less of an issue for a disc brake bike than rim riders. That pad material may be formulated to dissipate heat, but what about the rim itself? Some of the higher end bikes use aluminum rims, which can't use rim riders, since the added heat would deform them.When I rode the LandRider which shifted 7 engine/human driven gears automatically, I used rim brakes. Bike/rider weight was 350 lbs. I also live in the mountains. Down hill speeds can reach 50 mph. With rim brakes pads aren't created equally; a good quality compound pad is a must. Things like bump braking and longer stopping distance is required.
MY current bike the Sidewinder has front and rear disc. I still have to do bump braking going down steep hills but my stopping distance is shorter now.
Here I'm not disputing disc are better. However, I rode on rim brakes for 10 years without a single problem. Most of it is in knowing how to use them. For example if you have a STOP sign at the bottom of a long 30% grade hill, you can't ride your brakes all the way down the hill with rim or disc. What you do is bump brake so that the speed stays low enough to where you can stop at the sign. With rim brakes if you're at a high speed on level ground then you bump brake to slow down before applying full braking.With either type, heat is your enemy. At least with an open to the air rotor, heat is less of an issue for a disc brake bike than rim riders. That pad material may be formulated to dissipate heat, but what about the rim itself? Some of the higher end bikes use aluminum rims, which can't use rim riders, since the added heat would deform them.
No, like I said, once your top speed starts to go over 15-20 mph, discs all the way. Or big horken drum brakes, which have their own heat issues. Just ask any trucker trying to ride their brakes down Mt Eagle mtn...