Oil and fuel additives discussions often spawn little fights. Everyone has their own opinion on them. I just fail to see how an oil additive can affect the balance of an engines rotating parts and reduce vibration at all. I am also not a metallurgist, but I fail to see how an oil treatment can bond itself to metal parts, or "soak into" the micro pores enough to make any difference above and beyond good old oil. The companies that make "dura lube" and "slick 50" have had to settle with the FTC on unsubstantiated claims about their products. Take a close look at how oil additive companies word their product description and the disclaimers following clebrity endorsements, etc. I am sure that you are doing your engines no harm, so to each his own I suppose.
Personal anecdotal evidence in favor of Dura-Lube...
I tried the Slick50... It was total ****.
So it took quite a bit of convincing, to get me to try Dura-Lube.
But I did finally try it.
In a VERY tired old datsun engine.
It made immediate differences in the way the engine ran.
Increased the gas mileage significantly enough that you didn't even have to count the gallons and miles, it was evident on the fuel guage. But I counted anyway, and discovered I went from 15MPG to over 20.
Then, one night, someone came the wrong direction on the highway.
Forced me over the concrete meridian in the middle.
This tore a gash in the oil pan. I lost ALL oil, immediately.
Not having any money for a tow, I was in a quandary. I was only 3 miles from home. So... I decided to take a chance. Drive home, and watch the temp guage, and pay very close attention to any sounds, etc. Stop at the very first sign of trouble.
I drove all the way home, with the guage never going over 220 and absolutely no rough running, or sounds, etc.
Took the oil pan off, fixed the gash, reinstalled then filled again with oil and Dura-Lube. The engine never showed any sign whatever, of any damage. Gas mileage stayed up there. Etc.
I know only enough to know that I can't absolutely attribute all that to the Dura-Lube. You won't find me getting into a fight about it.
But I do know exactly what I wrote above. And the Dura-Lube was the only variable that I know of to attribute it to. Take it or leave it.
It left me open to the possibility that while there is no such thing as a miracle in a can... There IS a possibility that someone can come up with an additive that makes a difference.
I won't write off something that has good reviews, and no bad that I can find. Just because I believe there is no such thing as a miracle in a can.
It's not going to give me a completely new engine. It isn't going to triple my gas mileage. It isn't going to put shoes on my grandchildren's feet. And it isn't going to bring about world peace. But I'll try the motorkote, when I can afford it.