Ride hard means what? All the race guy's use aluminum frames and put more hp than most though them cornering as hard as possible usually to what ever the tires will permit which puts alot of stress on the frame on top of the engines drive line stresses and again fair well. Now when it comes to riding the street and trails or where ever and you have to deal with bumps, holes, rut's and such low speeds is not too bad but hit a hole at 50+ or catch a rut the wrong way and well hopefully your a good rider or you may be doing some damage and then yes aluminum is more likely to just break when severe enough. In most cases an aluminum frame is plenty strong or the downhill racers would be using something else also, this debate could be endless and really just comes down to personal preference and abilities.