Play with both the head gasket sizes/stacking as well as the base gasket.The base gaskets are likely a different size anyways. You might get a combo that'll work.
The base gaskets I buy are from bicycleengines.com. they have the best prices on those.
Your source for 2-Stroke and 4-Stroke Bicycle Engine Kits, Performance Parts, and Accessories!
www.bicycle-engines.com
I can let you know the exact thickness of those when I get off work.