Fix It.
Hey Tyler, Just my opinion, If it were my engine I would buy a wrist pin and bearing and clips, a piston and rings, slap it together and see what happens. IF, as you say, the cylinder wall is not scored, AT ALL, and your bottom end is still tight with no play between the rod and crank, and the crank bearings are good, then it should rebuild pretty easy. I wouldn't tear apart a bottom end unless it needed fixing. Like my Pop's always said, If it ain't broke, don't fix it. Wait untill you REALLY break one to tear one apart. And this way you'll have a spare engine when (not if) you need it.
Just be carefull putting on the rings. There are little pins in the ring slot that the ends of the rings set on. The rings will break very easy if not set in the slot properly.
And about those gaskets. I guess you could cut yer own if you're REALLY, REALLY, REALLY, (REALLY,) good. But dude, just buy em.
Big Red.